The 100 Greatest Albums in Christian Music — #76: Randy Stonehill, Return To Paradise (1989)

Intro

Landing at #76 in The 100 Greatest Albums in Christian Music, Randy Stonehill’s Return to Paradise (1989) finds the veteran songwriter marrying sharp narrative detail to radio‑ready melodies. It is equal parts journal and jubilee.

The Album in Context

Stonehill, a pillar of Jesus Music, entered the late ’80s with renewed clarity: big hooks, clean production, and lyrics that remembered the street while loving the sanctuary. The album strikes a balance between jangling uptempo cuts and ballads that resonate like cherished letters. Guitars sparkle, keyboards chime, and the rhythm section keeps everything moving without crowding the vocal.

Within CCM’s maturing pop landscape, Return to Paradise demonstrated that grown‑up concerns—loneliness, memory, perseverance—could live inside catchy, singable arrangements. Its emotional honesty helped widen the genre’s storytelling bandwidth beyond slogans and into human detail.

Standout Songs

• “Strong Hand of Love” — A career‑defining ballad that became a standard across tribute projects—melodic grace carrying a theology of mercy. Its enduring life beyond the album speaks to Stonehill’s gift for writing songs the church wants to keep singing.
• “Christmas at Denny’s” — A cinematic short story of holiday loneliness that refuses sentimentality. By naming pain in specific detail, the song dignified listeners who spend December in the margins—and pointed them toward light.
• “This Friend of Old” — Testimony wrapped in pop craftsmanship, balancing nostalgia with present‑tense faith. It’s Stonehill’s trademark: wit, warmth, and a chorus that invites you to join.

Why It Matters

Artistically, the album codified Stonehill’s influence on Christian pop craft: choruses you remember, verses you want to quote, and bridges that feel inevitable. Production choices emphasize clarity and warmth, ensuring the songs endure beyond their sonic trends.

Spiritually, it models discipleship in ordinary time—faith that keeps showing up, mercy that keeps holding on. Its songs have mentored writers and comforted listeners, proving that pop can still carry profound truth.

What’s Next

Next in The 100 Greatest Albums in Christian Music countdown is #75: the Imperials’ One More Song for You (1979)—a landmark of studio excellence and gospel‑pop conviction. Be sure to catch the companion podcast episode of The CCM Professor with Greg Rice, where we connect the dots between these landmark recordings.

Soli Deo Gloria!

This post is part of the series The 100 Greatest Albums in Christian Music, celebrating the artists and recordings that defined a generation of faith-filled creativity.

As an Amazon Associate, CCM Professor may earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links. Your support helps keep this series going!